Romana's Self-Assessment
What I am saying here is quite different than what I had said
just a couple of years ago, due to a somewhat clueless understanding of my
inner
nature,
and due to my gradual rate of real-life progression. My understanding of
myself is closely tied to my interactive real life experiences, and my
specific expression is always changing and in motion. I am also constantly
changing my mind, which should not be surprising, since I am moving toward
a more feminine persona.
The overriding reason for my expression as a transwoman, in preference to
being a man, is that my life works better that way. My lifelong
speech impediment, severe stammering, almost magically vanished. I am socially
and politically involved, though not without a certain amount of discrimination;
however, I am never sure whether people are uncomfortable with me as a transwoman,
or because I am a shy, introverted analyst, a techie.
When dressed as a woman,
not only do I feel free to express myself emotionally and stylistically as
a
woman,
I also feel free to transgress many limitations that are placed on women.
After all, we share one feature with genetic women: they are practically
never given permission to be themselves. I actually prefer dresses and skirts
to
men's
clothing,
especially
since,
whenever I wear a suit and a tie, I practically burn up from overheating.
Due to a strong sense of individuality, I really do not want to look like everyone
else. In man-mode, this can lead to unwanted cultural policing, but in woman-mode,
this is considered standard operating procedure.
The elements of my personality
and my journey do not necessarily seem to be complementary:
- I am shy, introverted,
and easily embarrassed; yet, I boldly express myself in public.
- I am not exactly zealous or driven, but I have increasingly
bold real life experiences. I seem to have no fear, and I have a high risk-taking
index. I have advanced by taking my wife's advice and the advice of many
others, and by making my woman-image as professional as possible.
- I am very conservative. Ideally, I would be a Republican;
unfortunately, the Republican Party has been taken over by political and
religious extremists. Civil rights, fiscal responsibility, ethics, and
peaceful means of solving problems are all conservative values.
- I am not religious; yet, I do faithfully attend my church.
I am only interested in spirituality and principles of faith, not dogma
or doctrine.
- I am extremely transgendered,
but I move more easily mainstreaming in the straight community, than I
do mixing in the trans-community.
- I did not start my journey thinking that my transgendered
identity was my true identity. Once I realized I had sufficient skill,
I experimentally
began a series of increasingly bolder real life experiences. Not long ago,
I suddenly realized that my entire self-assessment of myself had been mistaken;
my transgendered identity is quite real, after all.
- Since the presence of (genetic) women is my trigger, and
since I naturally want to be like the kind of people (women) that I am
attracted to, it would (erroneously) seem that my expression could
lead credence to Ray Blanchard's theory of autogynephilia. My
situation is erotically loaded, though there is no specific erotic content
or feelings
in my expression.
It is people like me Blanchard is trying to explain, but he would never
have allowed someone such as myself in his study, since I am not predictable.
We are all sexual persons, so all
this
qualifying
of people's
sexuality can, of course, lead to nonsense.
A generation ago, people like myself did not get to express
their true gender nature at all. The more trails we blaze, the more types of
trans-persons will come out and identify themselves. A key ingredient of
my expression is fitting into the world, not fitting particular definitions.
I am extremely fortunate to have a wife who
is ultra supportive, despite the fact that none of this is her idea.
Other couples often wonder how we do this, but there is no simple answer.
I can think
is that my wife somewhat agrees with my self-assessment, subject to a considerable
amount of discussion and evaluation.
There are certain characteristics of my expression that make
it more feasible and promote spousal support:
- My public expression is free of any flamboyant elements
that would attract undue attention and invalidate who I think I
am. I make crossdressing look very boring.
- I pass in the upper 20% of transwomen. This is great, but
it is also problematic, since a certain percentage of people will visually
read me.
- My height has shrunk to five feet, eight inches.
- I have excellent skin
tones
for someone
who is 62 years old.
- I am not interested in men. I am not being good; I am simply
not interested in men.
- I do not set
up love relationships with other women. I do meet women
with whom I could get involved; I know better than to be so reckless.
- I do not have any problems in women's restrooms.
- I, and my wife, have learned how to behave in public in
a manner that minimizes problems and tension.
- We dutifully go to therapy, where we even discuss the hot
buttons.
- I do not have another life, separate from our relationship.
- I would never refer to my wife as a lesbian, or to myself
as a male lesbian.
- I have never been influenced much by peer pressure, so if
another trans-person undergoes some fantastic transformation, I feel no
particular pressure emulate her.
- I have no preoccupations with pornography or she-male shenanigans.
- I respect my wife's space and possessions, as well
as her right to maintain her wardrobe and accessories too.
My wife is ultra supportive, despite the fact that she is not
exactly thrilled about my alternate gender expression. While my wife is extremely
helpful to make sure that I master the basics and look proper as a woman,
I am driving the whole process. I know how this gender thing works for a
lot of other couples, and almost none
of
these
couples
are so
bold
that
they
go
just about
anywhere,
even
in the
same
social settings, no matter how the husband might be dressed. We do not play
any games of trading privileges for other privileges, or labeling my behavior
as being good or bad, just because I am expressing myself as a woman. However,
I do try to be extra attentive to my wife's needs, so that our life is not
all about my gender expression, but she says our life always revolves
around my alternate gender identity, causing her unwanted emotional stress.
I try to set boundaries and limitations on myself, but I have
already learned that, in my case, static conditions simply do not work. If
I were a simple crossdresser, my situation would be more straight forward,
but I am now functioning much like a woman, a transwoman, to be more correct.
There is nothing wrong with being a crossdresser; the problem for me is that,
I
want
some
kind of
legal
status,
but there is
now a cultural war under way, waged by right-wing extremists, to prevent
crossdressers from gaining any legal status. It is not just the fact
I really prefer to be wearing dresses and
skirts;
there
are
some
key
attributes
of
my expression
that indicate the nature and the severity of my gender identity:
- This is about identity for me, not simply about the kind
of clothing I want to wear. I view my transwoman-identity as my actual,
objectified identity, and I am quite comfortable being this way in public
situations.
- I can and do go nearly anywhere in transwoman-mode, any
time of the day.
- Hundreds of people know me in both gender-modes. My expression
is discreet, not secret.
- My frequency of expression is now at 75%, with possible
short spikes to 95%.
- I am totally uninterested in lingerie; women's clothing
does not turn me on.
- I never wear women's underwear under men's clothing, or
vice versa. While I do have two women's nighties, I seldom ever wear them
to bed.
- I do not use colored nail polish, and I only have a couple
pair of high-heeled shoes.
- My expression does not saturate after a few days, leaving
me with an overwhelming desire to go home and change back to man-mode.
I have a sense of loss going from transwoman-mode to man-mode, but not
going from man-mode to transwoman-mode.
- My deep, inner image of myself is like that of a genetic
woman. Still, it is my version of a woman, not some stereotypical kind
of female impersonation.
- My expression has always been very public, and I do not
avoid difficult interactions with other people, especially with strangers.
I also never use darkness, or my wife, as a shield.
I have lived a fairly clueless life, ignoring all the obvious
indicators for my true identity. I now freely admit that I am transsexually-oriented.
However, since I now view myself to be much more like a woman than a man,
I end up in this Catch-22 situation,
where, as a woman, I do not get to do whatever I want. As a woman, I have
to be
relationship oriented.
This
is
not about
being good or bad; it is about working to manage the problem, while dropping
expectations of finding actual solutions. This is why I have chosen a methodology
of expression that will not be constant, and will actually vary all the time.
My expression is pretty much unbounded, but I do have to follow
rules, or else my wife would not trust me. The following rules
are not likely to change:
- Full gender reassignment surgery is not allowed. I have
no right to divert our funds to pay for such an undertaking, and I am not
going to get permission from my wife or from our therapist. This is not
about my psychological qualifications; rather, this is about support and
trust, and the impact on those close to me. Fortunately, this is not of
the utmost importance to me, especially since I am woman-identified,
not female-identified. I am also aware that full gender reassignment surgery
is not the only way that one can legally become a woman.
- Neither going full-time as a woman, nor changing my legal
name are allowed. This is inconvenient for me, but extremely convenient
for my wife, since I will be able to fully pass as a man for at least 5%
of the situations where I must simply appear to be a normal husband.
If I do not change my legal name, there will be no constant clues (such
as the names on our checks) that will alert everyone to what is going on.
- I am not allowed to purposely reveal my transwoman identity
to certain of my wife's friends and associates. Many of these people have
seen me physically dressed and probably deduced what has been going on,
but they have not had to deal with any issues. This is the most inconvenient
rule for me, so I have made it all a game, in which I cleverly talk around
the actual topic, but where blatantly revealing myself is an illegal move.
- If my wife says that some feature of my presentation needs
adjustment, I am expected to respond to her comments, and at least discuss
it, and possibly make changes.
Definitions are important; unfortunately, they have become
part of turf wars in the trans-community, which even include total denial
of all connections to and sole proprietorships of these definitions. Definitions
often serve to establish whatever legal status is possible, so many will
view any changes in scope as a form of hijacking.
Technically, I am transsexual, except for the notion of being trapped in
the wrong body, based on the original meaning of the word, before gender
reassignment became readily
available.
Since I
have
been
advised
that I ought not define myself that way, I usually refer to myself as a transwoman,
extremely transgendered, or even a serious crossdresser, living a dual-gendered
life. I do not like being referred
to
as a T-girl, as a trannie, or as a
transgenderist.
These terms simply do not convey the serious degree of my true gender identity.
My assessment of myself is not a spur-of-the-moment thing, since it only
comes after accumulating more than two years worth of recent real life experience.
I express myself publicly without the benefit of any kind of
woman identification. I once thought I passed really great, and many have
told me how well I passed, but I now wonder if a lot of this skill is just
self delusion. I think I actually succeed by just boldly presenting myself
as if I belong there, while creating a comfortable looking image at the
same time. Sometimes I warn people, but I do not give perfect strangers any
kind of a warning. I once thought I would have to explain things, but I have
dropped that idea, since I have discovered that most people actually do not
want
to discuss complex gender issues. By not explaining anything, I also do not
get into the trap of evaluating whether people are conservative or liberal,
or religious (especially fundamentalist) or non-religious. In a one-on-one
situation, people's philosophies do not predict how they are going to react
(to me.)
I never pretend to be a genetic woman, so there is no element of deceit
in my presentation.
I am
not stealthy,
just
discreet, while trying to minimize the impact I have on people. I tend to
disorient cashiers, and probably others, at times.
I have been told that I have no fear when expressing myself as a transwoman.
This alone can get me a long way in the real world.
I am still trying to figure out how I fit into any kind of
gender spectrum. There is some evidence that the largest subgroup of seriously
transgendered persons is husbands who could be described as non-transitioning
transsexuals.
We learn to express ourselves, while maintaining our support systems, without
attracting
a lot
of attention.
Not long ago, I was in total denial of my transgendered nature. I have not
adjusted to any of this without a great deal of resistance. Until recently,
I did not even think I was a feminine person, despite all the indicators
to the contrary. Still, even though I often explore new styles of women's
clothing, I would not be caught dead in 80% of the range of what women wear.
Things I have done en femme:
- Attended my 40th high school reunion
- Eaten at about 100 restaurants, mostly with my wife.
- Bought a minivan.
- Gone to the symphony, opera, ballet, and Broadway shows.
- Gone to the dentist.
- Gone to the doctor.
- Gone to the optometrist.
- Gone to the veterinarian.
- Had laser hair removal treatment. Only eye makeup was allowed,
but I was allowed to shave.
- Had electrolysis. Only eye makeup was allowed, and whiskers
not to be removed during a session were shaved.
- Gone to church: Unity, American Baptist, and Unitarian,
but not to my wife's LDS church.
- Gone shopping, even at home improvement and auto supply
stores.
- Taken our cars in for servicing.
- Gone to work, when I had a job, subject to all sorts of
restrictions.
- Gone to the pharmacy, where they recognize me in both gender-modes.
- Gone across the street to our daughter's house. Since the
grandson has shown no desire to crossdress, our daughter no longer worries
about corrupting him.
- Gone to endless GLBT support meetings.
- Gone to my Democratic precinct meetings.
- Visited my legislators.
- Gone to political rallies.
- Had a mammogram.
- Seen at least twelve movies.
- Attended the Mormon Tabernacle Choir in Salt Lake City.
- Gotten my real hair cut (i.e., I took off the wig.)
- Gone to my wig salon.
- Waved campaign signs at street corners, and drove people
to the polls on election day.
- Been in in automobile accident. This was one experience
that I did not want to have. This included interaction with the investigating
police officer, as well as taking the car to the auto body shop for the
repair estimate.
- I have experienced twenty-one hours of Richard Wagner's
Der Ring des Nibelungen, series II, at the Seattle Opera in mid-August,
2005.
Things I have not yet done en femme:
- I have not yet flown on scheduled (or any other) jet airliner.
I understand that others have done it with a kind of non-legal dual identification
card, but the security response to the attack on the World Trade Center
has made
this a capricious undertaking. This would have been trivial before 9/11,
because
residents of the State of Washington were previously allowed to get a state
ID card for their woman-identity. I seldom travel without my wife,
so I am not likely to get spousal permission, since my wife would view
traveling with me en femme on an airliner as something that would
generate extreme anxiety.
- I have not yet wandered around on a cruise ship. I expect
to to this in the future, on a Hawaii Cruise, an Australia-New Zealand
cruise, and on a Baltic cruise. Of course, without proper identification,
I will
be
limited
to the area of the cruise ships in foreign ports.
- I have not yet gone to jury duty. I have discussed this
with a number of judges, and they have all assured me that I have the right
to do this, considering that it is normal for me, that I am not
trying to get out of jury duty by doing it, and that I am not doing it
as a stunt.
August
25, 2005